- ILA is not a legal requirement for these three agreements. The one place the Family Law Act demands it is family arbitration. [1] [3]
- The Ontario government's advice: "You and your partner should speak to different lawyers and exchange financial information before signing a marriage contract or cohabitation agreement." [4]
- A court can set an agreement aside for undisclosed significant assets or debts, a party who did not understand it, or under the law of contract. You cannot contract out of these grounds. [2]
- In a British Columbia case, the Supreme Court of Canada called ILA "an important means of ensuring an informed decision to enter an agreement." [7]
- ILA is not a shield. In Supreme Court of Canada cases from British Columbia and Saskatchewan, one agreement was found unconscionable where lawyers were involved, and another was enforced where they were not. [10] [13]
What independent legal advice means
Two people who sign a domestic contract are on opposite sides of it. Independent legal advice is advice from a lawyer who advises you and not your partner. The Ontario government's wording is "different lawyers," and it adds that "A mediator does not take the place of a lawyer." [4] [6]
The Supreme Court of Canada has said the involvement of counsel helps "make sure parties understand the terms and effect of their agreement, as well as the rights they are giving up under the relevant statutory scheme." [10] Advice and financial disclosure work together, because a person "may not know to request disclosure, and may not understand the legal significance of any assets that are disclosed without the advice of counsel." [10]
An ILA lawyer can be hired for that one job. Ontario's guidance says a lawyer can offer limited scope services, where the lawyer "provides you with initial advice or helps you with specific steps in your case." [4]
At Kazandji Law, ILA covers family law agreements: separation agreements, marriage contracts signed before the wedding (prenups) or after it (postnups), and cohabitation agreements.
Is independent legal advice required in Ontario?
For a separation agreement, marriage contract or cohabitation agreement, no. Section 55(1) of the Family Law Act says a domestic contract is "unenforceable unless made in writing, signed by the parties and witnessed." [1] Legal advice is not on that list. Reviewing provincial statutes in 2023, the Supreme Court listed Ontario among the provinces that add a disclosure requirement and named Alberta as one that requires independent legal advice. [10]
The exception is family arbitration. An arbitration decision in a family case is enforceable only if each party "receives independent legal advice before making the agreement" to arbitrate, and the lawyer "shall complete a certificate of independent legal advice." [3] A follow up arbitration held under an existing separation agreement, court order or earlier arbitration decision is exempt. [3]
The government still recommends advice for the other agreements. It tells couples to see different lawyers before a marriage contract or cohabitation agreement, and says of separation agreements: "You do not need a lawyer to make a separation agreement, but it is a good idea to get legal advice before you sign one." [4] [5]
How ILA connects to the grounds for setting an agreement aside
Section 56(4) gives a court three grounds to set aside a domestic contract or one of its terms, and section 56(7) says they apply despite any agreement to the contrary. [2] Each ground matches part of the lawyer's job.
| Ground in section 56(4) | What the ILA lawyer does about it |
|---|---|
| A party failed to disclose significant assets, debts or other liabilities that existed when the contract was made | Reviews the financial disclosure you were given and points out gaps the lawyer can see before you sign |
| A party "did not understand the nature or consequences" of the contract | Explains each term, and what the law would give you without the agreement |
| "otherwise in accordance with the law of contract" | Meets with you alone and asks how the deal was reached, so that you can raise any pressure before you sign |
Sources: [2] [7]. If you suspect the numbers are incomplete, see our post on what to do if your spouse is hiding assets.
What happens at an ILA meeting
- You send the documents first. The draft agreement with all schedules, and the financial disclosure exchanged so far.
- The lawyer reads the agreement against the default law. For married spouses that means equalization of net family property, rights in the matrimonial home and spousal support. Unmarried partners may have support rights but have no statutory property sharing, as our guide to common law breakups explains. [11]
- You meet without your partner. The lawyer asks who drafted the agreement, how long you have had it, whether anyone has set a deadline, and what you know about your partner's income, assets and debts.
- The lawyer explains each term and what it would mean on separation, on death, and if incomes or the family change.
- You hear the gaps and the options. Missing disclosure, terms a court could override, and changes worth asking for. [11] Whether to ask for them is your decision.
- You decide whether to sign. If you go ahead, you sign in front of a witness and the lawyer signs the certificate of independent legal advice. [1]
What to bring
- The complete draft agreement, including schedules.
- Financial disclosure from both sides: tax returns and notices of assessment, recent pay stubs, bank, investment and pension statements, mortgage statements, property appraisals and business financial statements.
- Any earlier agreement or court order between you. A cohabitation agreement signed before you married is now treated as a marriage contract. [12]
- Emails or texts that show how the terms were negotiated, and any deadline you have been given.
- Your questions, written down.
What ILA is not
- Negotiation for the other side. The lawyer advises you. Your partner's lawyer, if there is one, advises your partner.
- Joint advice. Lawyers owe each client a duty of loyalty that includes "a duty to avoid conflicting interests." [9] The Law Society of Ontario's rules say that, even if both clients consent, a lawyer should avoid acting for more than one client "when it is likely that a contentious issue will arise between them or their interests, rights or obligations will diverge as the matter progresses." [14]
- A mediator's summary. In the Ontario government's words, "A mediator does not take the place of a lawyer," and after mediation both people should get advice "from different lawyers" before signing. [6]
- A promise that the agreement will stand. The Supreme Court has said courts should not presume that legal advice immunizes a contract from unfairness. [10]
If the lawyer thinks the deal is unfair
Hartshorne v. Hartshorne shows how that can play out. The wife's lawyer told her in a written opinion that the marriage agreement was "grossly unfair" and recommended that she not sign it in that form. [7] She signed on the wedding day after small changes. When she later challenged it, the Supreme Court upheld the agreement, noting that she had reviewed its shortcomings with her lawyer: "If the respondent truly believed that the Agreement was unacceptable at that time, she should not have signed it." [7] That case was decided under British Columbia's Family Relations Act, which that province repealed in 2013, not under Ontario's Family Law Act.
How ILA affects a later court challenge
None of the Supreme Court of Canada decisions below was decided under Ontario's Family Law Act. Three turned on the statute involved and one, Rick, on the common law of unconscionability. The Court has said the analysis has to follow the statute in play. [10] Hartshorne itself pointed out that British Columbia's fairness test was easier to meet than the tests in other provinces, Ontario's section 56(4) among them. [7] The decisions still show how judges weigh legal advice.
| Case | Decided under | Legal advice | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Miglin v. Miglin, 2003 SCC 24 | Divorce Act, s. 15.2 (spousal support) | Both spouses had lawyers and negotiated for 15 months | Wife held to her release of spousal support [8] |
| Hartshorne v. Hartshorne, 2004 SCC 22 | British Columbia Family Relations Act (repealed in 2013) | Each spouse had legal advice. The wife was advised not to sign | Agreement upheld [7] |
| Rick v. Brandsema, 2009 SCC 10 | Common law unconscionability, British Columbia | Lawyers and mediators were involved on and off | Agreement found unconscionable. Husband ordered to pay $649,680 [13] |
| Anderson v. Anderson, 2023 SCC 13 | Saskatchewan Family Property Act | None, and no financial disclosure | Agreement enforced, though it lacked the acknowledgment in front of a lawyer that Saskatchewan requires for a formal contract [10] |
- Advice supports the agreement. In Hartshorne the Court said courts should be reluctant to interfere, "particularly where independent legal advice has been obtained." [7] In Miglin the Court said "The degree of professional assistance received by the parties will often overcome any systemic imbalances between the parties." [8]
- Advice does not cure everything. In Rick the husband hid assets and exploited his wife's mental instability, and the agreement was found unconscionable even though professionals were available to her: "exploitation is not rendered anodyne merely because a spouse has access to professional advice." [13]
- No advice does not sink an agreement by itself. In Anderson the Court said of Saskatchewan's statute that disclosure and legal advice "are not required by the legislation and their absence, without more, does not necessarily impugn the fairness of an agreement." [10] Ontario's Act is different on disclosure: failing to disclose significant assets or debts is a ground for setting an agreement aside. [2] The husband had been told to "think it over and talk to a lawyer," signed immediately, and was bound. [10]
Timing
As general guidance, do not sign on the day you first see an agreement. In Miglin the Supreme Court told judges to look at the conditions under which an agreement was negotiated, including how long the negotiations lasted and whether there was professional help. [8] Signing against a deadline did not undo the agreement in Hartshorne: it was signed on the wedding day at the husband's insistence, the trial judge found no duress, coercion or undue influence, and the Supreme Court upheld it. [7] Give yourself time to read the draft, see the disclosure, get advice and ask for changes. For a prenup, that means well before the wedding. If you have already signed without advice, have the agreement reviewed now: Anderson, a Saskatchewan case, shows that a signature given without a lawyer can still bind you. [10]
How Kazandji Law helps
We give independent legal advice before you sign, with a signed certificate of independent legal advice. We review separation agreements, marriage contracts and cohabitation agreements, including drafts prepared by your partner's lawyer or produced in family mediation.
We have offices in Toronto (180 John Street, Unit 320), Thornhill (7191 Yonge Street, Suite 310), North York (70 Forest Manor Road, Unit 4B) and Oakville (466 Speers Road). Call 647-588-3234 for a free consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is independent legal advice required for a separation agreement in Ontario?
What does an ILA lawyer do?
An ILA lawyer advises you and not your partner, explains what the agreement says and what rights you would give up, and reviews the financial disclosure you were given. [10]
Can my partner and I use the same lawyer for independent legal advice?
No. Advice is independent only if your lawyer is not also advising your partner. The Ontario government's guidance is that you and your partner "should speak to different lawyers." [4]
Can I still sign if my lawyer tells me the agreement is unfair?
Yes. The decision is yours. In Hartshorne v. Hartshorne, a British Columbia case, a wife who signed against her lawyer's written advice was later held to the agreement. [7]
Does independent legal advice make an agreement impossible to challenge?
No. Section 56(4) still applies. Significant assets or debts that were not disclosed, a party who did not understand the agreement, and contract law grounds all remain open. [2]
Related pages
Sources and legal references
- Family Law Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. F.3, s. 55(1). www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90f03
- Family Law Act, s. 56(4), (7). www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90f03
- Family Law Act, ss. 59.6(1)(b), 59.6(2), 59.7(1), 59.7(2). www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90f03
- Government of Ontario, "Dividing property when a marriage or common law relationship ends." www.ontario.ca/page/dividing-property-when-marriage-or-common-law-relationship-ends
- Government of Ontario, "Spousal support." www.ontario.ca/page/spousal-support
- Government of Ontario, "Family mediation." www.ontario.ca/page/family-mediation
- Hartshorne v. Hartshorne, 2004 SCC 22, paras. 1, 6, 14, 17, 60, 61, 63, 65, 67 (decided under British Columbia's Family Relations Act, s. 65, since repealed and replaced by the Family Law Act, S.B.C. 2011, c. 25). scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/2134/index.do
- Miglin v. Miglin, 2003 SCC 24, paras. 1, 11, 13, 81, 82, 92 (decided under the Divorce Act, s. 15.2). scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/2055/index.do
- Canadian National Railway Co. v. McKercher LLP, 2013 SCC 39, para. 19 (a lawyer's duty of loyalty at common law; a Saskatchewan commercial case, not a family law case). scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/13154/index.do
- Anderson v. Anderson, 2023 SCC 13, paras. 8, 12, 31 to 33, 35, 42, 45 to 49, 70, 71, 83 (decided under Saskatchewan's Family Property Act). scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/19906/index.do
- Family Law Act, ss. 1(1) "spouse", 5(1), 19(1), 29, 30, 33(4), 56(1), 56(1.1). www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90f03
- Family Law Act, s. 53(2). www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90f03
- Rick v. Brandsema, 2009 SCC 10, headnote and paras. 26 to 28, 35, 58, 60 to 62, 70 (British Columbia; common law unconscionability, with the Family Relations Act, since repealed, as the governing property statute). scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/6396/index.do
- Law Society of Ontario, Rules of Professional Conduct, Chapter 3, rule 3.4-7, commentary 1 (joint retainers). See also rules 3.4-3 and 3.4-5. lso.ca/about-lso/legislation-and-rules/rules-of-professional-conduct/chapter-3
This page provides general legal information and is not legal advice. Laws and procedures change; speak with a lawyer about your situation.

